A parallel tale of two cities

I just concluded reading the superb book Istanbul, Memories and the City, by Orhan Pamuk. If you have also had the pleasure of reading it, you may recall how eloquently Mr. Pamuk describes this majestic bi-continental metropolis as being in an extended state of melancholy since the decline and fall of the Ottoman Empire. To him, the melancholy was discernible in the decaying ruins, in the loss of prestige on the world stage, and in the deterioration of its historic identity. One contributing issue that he does not directly speak to, which may have also contributed to this malaise, was the transfer of the nation’s capital to Ankara in 1923.

It turns out that many of the same emotions Mr. Pamuk describes in his book have an astonishing parallel to general mood of another great city – Greater Detroit (Detroit-Windsor). In fact, there are several fascinating parallels between Istanbul and Detroit.

Istanbul, Turkey - Source: http://www.google.com

Detroit-Windsor, USA/Canada - Source: http://www.google.com

  • Geographically, both cities are among an elite group that developed and prospered along a strategic strait linking two important water bodies – in Istanbul’s case, it is the Bosphorus connecting the Black Sea and the Sea of Marmara. Meanwhile in Detroit, the city’s namesake and the St. Clair link Lake Huron with Lake Erie. None of these watery connections are true rivers, as they are misnamed – they are actually straits.
  • Istanbul is the primary link between Europe with Asia, while Detroit-Windsor is the busiest international trade crossing in North America and links the United States (Michigan) and Canada (Ontario).
  • As Istanbul was once the capital of the Ottoman Empire, Detroit was the original capital of Michigan until it was transferred to Lansing in 1847.
  • Both cities have recently re-awakened from their melancholy and have transformed into vibrant tigers (pun intended in Detroit’s case). Go Tigers!

To say the mood in Greater Detroit has been filled with cyclical bouts of melancholy for decades would be a huge understatement. Since the end of World War II, this region has suffered multiple economic, social, and political blows that would have surely knocked out a lesser combatant. Today, like its hometown hero Joe Louis rising from the canvas, there are visible, palpable, detectable, and viable signs of an economic resurgence in Greater Detroit. The same resurgence can be said about Istanbul – in fact this magnificent city has been dubbed “the world’s hippest city”. Likewise, Greater Detroit has had more positive press in the past 12 months than the past 12 years combined.  It has been described as the new Bohemian hot spot in America.

As a resident of Michigan, I am very hopeful for the future of Greater Detroit. Despite what some may say, Michigan will never fully recover unless Detroit heals too.  As one who has longed to travel to Istanbul, I am inspired by that city’s similar resurgence and hope to visit there in the not-too-distant future. As an urban planner, I am intrigued by the fascinating similarities between these two world champion heavyweights. Watch out competition, both Istanbul and Detroit are back!

This entry was posted in architecture, art, cities, culture, diversity, economic development, history, land use, planning, poverty, revitalization and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to A parallel tale of two cities

  1. Jud says:

    I enjoyed reading this comparison of the influence of social and economic factors on the percieved and actual rise and fall of Detroit and Istanbul. I am happy to hear they are both on the rise.

    Like

  2. It seems you don’t read what you site: The decline in city’s pop. was a result of the ethnic minorities expelled:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Istanbul#Demographics
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_exchange_between_Greece_and_Turkey

    Like

  3. Janna Liliya says:

    I made a package tour reservation for 4 nights and 5 days with this Private Tours in Istanbul on the internet and i had great days with a good price in Istanbul thanks to them. They picked me up from Airport to the hotel. They arranged me a 4 stars hotel in old city area (very close to main attractions as hagia sophia or blue mosque). http://www.privatetoursinistanbul.com visited a lot of places during these days and all of them were worth to see. For example Dolmabahce Palace, Hagia Sophia, Topokapi Palace, Blue Mosque and of course the Turkish night. On the Turkish night we had the chance to see the traditional dances of Turkey and the same time we could see the Bosphorus during having our dinner. If you want to see a coplex of religions you must visit the Hagia Sophia; Byzantium, Ottoman and Pagan religions are complete each other. We had different guides but all of them were very kind and knowlageble. So the tours were great the hotel was perfect. I left them to do my program and i only applied. I had a good experiance in Istanbul.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.