A month or two ago I wrote my Congressman, Republican Mike Rogers about ending subsidies for oil and gas companies. Today, I received a response in the mail. His letter was very cordial and polite, but the logic of his argument is simply laughable.
“Like you, I am concerned with the high price of oil and gasoline, and I believe that the oil industry must be closely monitored for anti-trust violations. That said, I have serious concerns with raising taxes on any employers, especially now when Americans are struggling to pay for gasoline.” (underline emphasis added)
SOURCE: Letter from Mike Rogers dated July 10, 2012
Are you freakin’ kidding me? Eliminating subsidies is raising taxes? Who the hell came up with that logic? Since when did eliminating a subside become a tax increase? Sir, these idiotic subsides cost all of us from $10-52 billion per year. That’s money that could be put too much better use funding renewable energy, feeding the malnourished, carrying for the poor and unemployed, or at the very least helping homeless veterans.
“In the United States, credible estimates of annual fossil fuel subsidies range from $10 billion to $52 billion annually, while even efforts to remove small portions of those subsidies have been defeated in Congress, as shown in the graphic below. Download your own pdf copy here.” SOURCE: priceofoil.org
Meanwhile, Congressman, big oil reaps larger and larger profits at our expense. According to priceofoil.org,
” the top five oil companies alone have made almost a trillion dollars in profit in the last decade.”
So, I have no idea where Congressman Rogers gets the idea that ending subsides amounts to a tax increase. My guess is some anal-retentive GOP think tank funded by big oil came up with that bilge of an argument. All I know is it is one of the most illogical things I have ever heard, let alone read.
Reblogged this on emmageraln.
When I was growing up, my father always used to say to me, “Son, if you want to get to the bottom of any issue, look for the guy who’s making the buck”.
Obviously, “the guy” making the buck here is the oil companies who undoubtedly fund Congressman Roger’s reelection campaigns so naturally, he is going to say anything they want to say no matter how ridiculous it is.
I agree with you 100%. Given his line of logic, every social program that has been cut, is also a tax increase. Does the GOP really want to go down that path?
Thank you for this, Rick. Rogers is my Congressman as well and I have written him three times about the ongoing Enbridge debacle in Michigan. I have yet to receive any acknowledgment whatsoever.
I have started a blog about Ebridge’s current activities: http://grangehallpress.com/Enbridgeblog/
Thanks for letting me know. Good luck with your blog.